Skip to main content

Former Ag Minister gets Suspended Death Sentence

Tang Renjian, China's Minister of Agriculture from 2020 to 2024, was given a death sentence with a 2-year reprieve for taking bribes totaling RMB 284 million, according to China's central news organization. Like most things in China, this is probably not what it appears to be. 

Former Agriculture Minister Tang Renjian in court.

The Changchun Intermediate People's Court of Jilin Province found former Party Secretary of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs (MARA) Tang Renjian guilty of taking bribes during his tenure at various posts from 2007 to 2024. Tang was accused of using his power and status to assist units and individuals in business operations, project contracts, and job adjustments. Earlier this year, Radio Free Asia reported that Tang was accused of accepting gifts and property for help in business deals, favoring relatives, making "blind decisions" in poverty alleviation programs, and interfering in judicial decisions. It sounds like Tang acted like any other communist official in China.

He was deprived of political rights for life, and all his personal property was confiscated and turned over to the state treasury. 

Tang had been removed from his post as agriculture minister and investigated in May 2024. The investigation was completed in April 205 and the Supreme Peoples Procuratorate referred the case to Changchun for prosecution.

A number of aspects of this case seem puzzling. 

Why was the trial held in Changchun? None of Tang's postings were anywhere near Jilin Province. Is it common to prosecute individuals in regions unrelated to the crimes? 

His death sentence was delayed (effectively suspended) because Tang confessed his crimes, revealed additional facts previously unknown to authorities when he was arrested, and expressed his guilt in court. Yet the description of Tang's trial says that he and his attorney cross-examined witnesses, implying that Tang contested his guilt. 

Tang doesn't fit the profile of corrupt bureaucrat. Tang appears to have been a policy wonk with a doctorate in agricultural economics, and his jobs in research institutes and the Central Leading Groups on Finance and Poverty Alleviation do not look like prime bribe-generating opportunities. His posting as Guangxi party secretary lasted 2 years, his posting as deputy party secretary and governor of Gansu Province lasted 3 years, and he was MARA minister less than 4 years, seemingly not long enough to establish a power base to generate bribes. How did he manage to get bribes while moving from post to post and different provinces. Guangxi and Gansu are relatively poor provinces and MARA probably has one of the smallest budgets of any ministry in China. 

Tang's RMB 268 million (about USD 38 million) in bribes was described as "extremely large," but this is not that much for a Chinese minister, member of the central committee and member of the National Peoples Congress to have taken over 17 years. If bribery is their concern, authorities could have found much bigger perps in banks and ministries that oversee real estate and industry. 

The bribery charges are most likely a sham, covering up political intrigue or some other "crime". Various theories about Tang's arrest have been put forth, but none appear to be convincing at this point.

Tang Renjian was sent to meet U.S. agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack in an
attempt to mend ties several months before his arrest.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Xi Jinping's Doctoral Thesis

Xi Jinping is the vice president and presumed next president of China but little is known about him. In this post the dimsums blog offers its contribution to the genre of Xi Jinping-ology by conveying Xi's decade-old views on agricultural markets. Ten years ago Xi Jinping wrote a thesis, "Tentative Study of Agricultural Marketization" (äø­å›½å†œę‘åø‚åœŗ化ē ”ē©¶) for a Doctor of Law degree at Tsinghua University in Beijing, a top breeding-ground for Chinese officials. The dimsums blogger has spent several hours poring over the 200-plus page tome to see what it reveals about Dr. Xi. The thesis is remarkably close to what China has been doing lately in agricultural policy, suggesting that Xi (or the person who actually wrote the thesis) has a major say in policy or is at least in agreement with what's being done. There is nothing adventurous, controversial (or insightful) in the thesis. It seems to be the work of a wonkish technocrat who is not prone to talk out of turn or wander from...
15 comments
Read more

Divergence in U.S. & Chinese egg prices

High egg prices are a hot topic in the United States. China, in contrast, has a glut of eggs and depressed prices.  The March 14, 2025 USDA Agricultural Marketing Service weekly eggs market overview reported that U.S. egg prices continued declining during the second week of March as the supply situation improved. No significant highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) outbreaks have occurred in March and U.S. egg demand is relatively light. The average U.S. wholesale price for Grade A large white eggs was $4.15 per dozen, down sharply from their February peak.  Until 2021, Chinese and U.S. wholesale egg prices had been roughly equal at about $1-to-$2 per dozen with no trend. U.S. prices fluctuated more than Chinese prices, so the U.S. price was sometimes higher, sometimes lower than the Chinese price after converting them to dollars per dozen.  Chinese prices converted using monthly exchange rate and assuming 0.6 kg per dozen. Sources: USDA and China Ministry of Agricult...
Post a Comment
Read more

China's Corn & Wheat Imports Down 97% From Last Year

China's first customs data for 2025 feature a 97-percent decline in corn and wheat imports from a year earlier. Soybean imports were up slightly by volume (but down in value), and dairy, pork, poultry, and seafood imports rebounded year-on-year. Life was less sweet in China with a 93.7% decline in sugar imports, and drinking appears to be up as wine and beer imports posted gains.   China's agricultural imports for January-February 2025 were down 14.7 percent from a year earlier. The value of farm and food goods imported for the first two months of 2025 totaled $30.7 billion, down $5.26 billion from the same period in 2024. China's exports of agricultural products during January-February totaled $15.2 billion, up $393 million from a year earlier.  Data from China Customs Administration website. As usual, soybeans were the largest component of China's agricultural imports during January-February 2025 with a value of $6.3 billion. Meat imports were valued at $4.1 billion, ...
2 comments
Read more