Dim Sums: Agricultural Markets in China

China has been massaging data on soybean imports and consumption of soybean meal to hide the failure of its policies aimed at reducing reliance on imported soybeans. Last month China's customs data reported that 99.41 million metric tons (mmt) of soybeans were imported during the 2023 calendar year, an 11.41% increase from 89.218 mmt imported during 2022. However, adding up the monthly soybean import totals reported by customs over the last 12 months gives me a bigger total of 101.71 mmt for 2023. That would have been a record amount, exceeding the previous record of 100.3 mmt imported during calendar year 2020. What happened? The 99.41 mmt total appears to have been doctored to whittle down the annual total and keep it under the symbolic 100-mmt barrier. A record soybean import total would have drawn attention to the failure of highly publicized and costly Chinese policies to reduce reliance on imported soybeans. The revisions also foil a prediction that China's soybean imp...

It's said that doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results is the definition of insanity. By that definition China's agricultural policy is insane.  This month China released the latest in a string of "No. 1 Documents" on rural priorities issued each year since 2004. (An earlier set was issued from 1982-86.) The same programs keep coming up, often with the exact same language. Some long-forgotten programs are intermittently resurrected despite having failed in the past.  This year's document has several failed programs resurrected from the dead. The document directs provinces to experiment with a "dynamic mechanism" linking farm input subsidies to rises in input prices. This apparently is institutionalizing the so-called "one-time subsidies" given to compensate farmers for high input prices each of the last 3 years. The subsidies were given out in 2-to-4-billion-yuan tranches in an ad hoc manner, multiple times in ...